The idea, in plain language
Culture is not just a feeling; it is a tracking system for where rich people feel safe spending, showing off, borrowing, and moving.
When taste shifts, money shifts. Not instantly, but reliably enough that you can treat culture like an early warning dashboard.
You already know the obvious version: when a city becomes “cool,” capital follows. The deeper version is: you can measure this using repeatable signals.
What counts as “culture data,” not gossip
If you want a real “culture index,” you need indicators that are:
- measurable (prices, volumes, allocations, default rates, migration)
- repeatable (updated quarterly or annually)
- hard to fake (requires real transactions)
Here are the strongest signals to watch, and why they map to wealth flows.
Signal 1: the “investments of passion” indexes
Knight Frank runs a Luxury Investment Index that tracks a basket of collectible categories and explicitly uses data sources like Art Market Research, Fancy Color Research Foundation, HAGI (cars), Rare Whisky 101, and Liv-ex (wine).
Why this matters: it is a cross-category temperature check. If the basket is falling while financial markets are rising, it often means discretionary “status capital” is getting cautious, not because people are poor, but because they are re-pricing risk.
Knight Frank’s Wealth Report 2025 highlights that a basket of 10 leading collectibles fell by an average of 3.3% in 2024, and notes that art underperformed sharply (down 18.3% in that discussion).
Interpretation:
- when passion assets soften, buyers get picky
- liquidity concentrates in top names, top condition, top paperwork
- marginal categories suffer first, that is your “risk-off” culture signal
Signal 2: fine wine as a “liquidity proxy” for taste
Liv-ex publishes widely used wine price indices. The Liv-ex Fine Wine 100 is described by Liv-ex as an industry leading benchmark that monitors fine wine prices and tracks the price movement of 100 highly sought-after wines on the secondary market.
Why wine is useful as a culture signal:
- it trades globally, mostly among sophisticated buyers
- it is heavily driven by confidence and discretionary spending
- it is sensitive to storage quality and authenticity, which mirrors broader “paperwork premium” dynamics
If wine indices sag while luxury retail still looks glossy, that can be a canary. It suggests collectors are demanding better pricing and better quality, even if the Instagram layer looks fine.
Signal 3: cars and whisky, the “high-ticket hobby” barometer
HAGI publishes indices for historic automobiles, including the HAGI Top Index described as an overall market measure for exceptional historic automobiles. Rare Whisky 101 publishes the Apex 1000 Index, described as a broad measurement tracking the best performing 1,000 bottles of rare whisky.
Why these categories predict wealth flows:
- they are high-discretion purchases
- they depend on specialized storage, insurance, and trusted dealers
- when confidence drops, buyers step back fast
When these markets cool, it usually means one of two things:
- wealthy buyers are rotating into experiences, travel, property, or core financial assets
- wealthy buyers are still spending, but only on “trophy grade,” meaning the middle gets crushed
Signal 4: luxury retail discounting, the status machine slipping
Financial Times reporting points to rising luxury discounting and consumer pushback after years of price increases, with commentary that consumers are shifting toward experiences and emotional fulfillment rather than pure material luxury.
This matters for Tier 2/3 because luxury retail is often the “front office” of aspirational demand. When discounting rises, it signals:
- the marginal buyer is strained or bored
- brands lose pricing power
- resale markets can soften because supply rises and hype cools
This tends to hit places that depend on “tourist luxury,” and it boosts places that sell “lifestyle + systems,” meaning residency pathways, banking rails, family governance, and stable property rights.
Signal 5: art allocations, art market health, and leverage stress
The Art Basel and UBS Survey of Global Collecting 2025 reports that high-net-worth collectors allocated an average of 20% of their wealth to art in 2025, up from 15% in 2024.
At the same time, parts of the art finance world are showing stress. Financial Times reporting, citing the Deloitte Private and ArtTactic Art and Finance Report 2025, said defaults on art-backed loans surged for non-bank lenders in 2024, alongside a contracting art market.
This combination is the kind of “culture index paradox” you should love:
- people say they want art and allocate more to it
- credit against art becomes riskier when prices soften and liquidity thins
Interpretation:
- wealthier, more sophisticated collectors keep buying
- leverage against art becomes more fragile at the margin
- the market splits into “bankable art” and “non-bankable art”
That split is a wealth flow signal. In Tier 2/3 markets, it shows up as: money prefers assets with clean provenance, clean custody, clean compliance, and clear exit routes.
Signal 6: wealth migration, where people physically move their balance sheets
Henley & Partners’ press release for the Private Wealth Migration Report 2025 states that a record 142,000 millionaires are projected to relocate internationally in 2025.
Why migration belongs in the Culture Index:
- when people move, they bring demand for property, private banking, education, healthcare, and status networks
- they shift art buying, club memberships, and luxury consumption to the new hub
- they change local politics and rules, which feeds back into risk and opportunity
So culture and mobility are inseparable. The cities winning wealth inflows become the new “taste capitals,” and then the taste capitals attract more capital.
How to build a Culture Index dashboard for Tier 2/3 allocators
You do not need fancy math. You need consistency.
Pick 10 indicators and update them monthly or quarterly:
- KFLII direction and best-performing categories
- Liv-ex Fine Wine 100 direction
- HAGI Top Index commentary and direction
- Rare Whisky 101 Apex 1000 direction
- luxury discounting and pricing power headlines
- art collecting allocation shifts
- art finance stress headlines
- millionaire migration direction and major destination hubs
- premium property transaction energy in your target hubs (local data source)
- regulatory friction index (sanctions, KYC intensity, customs seizures in your corridors)
Then score each 0 to 2:
- 0 = risk-off signal
- 1 = neutral
- 2 = risk-on signal
Add them up. That is your Culture Index.
What the Culture Index tells you to do, not just “know”
When the index trends risk-off:
- underwrite collectibles like private credit, demand proof, demand exit plans
- prioritize bankable assets, clean title, audited custody, and known buyers
- expect more “forced sellers,” and negotiate hard
When the index trends risk-on:
- expect faster price spikes in status categories
- expect more cross-border movement and more opportunistic buying
- expect more scams, because heat attracts predators
Bottom line
Taste trends are a leading indicator because they reveal where wealthy people feel confident. Track the data-driven parts of culture, not the hype. When collectibles soften, defaults rise in art finance, and luxury discounting increases, wealth flows toward stability, compliance, and systems. When confidence returns, the status machine restarts, and Tier 2/3 hubs that can handle access and paperwork win.
Written by
